Firehouses: History Versus Safety

There was an article in the New York Times recently reporting that the US Coast Guard has increased the average body weight calculation for passengers where commercial boating is concerned.  The old weight was 160 and the new one is 185.  Surprise:  people are getting bigger, fast.

It seems that fire trucks  and ambulances are following this same trend. Are firefighters also getting bigger or do we just need more stuff?  Or, maybe it is a little bit of both.

Whatever the cause, bigger fire rigs are creating tension (and problems) in older areas where the existing firehouses may have both historical value and be subject to preservation restrictions where any changes to the structure are subject to approval.

Such is the case here in Washington, D.C., where a host of firehouses built in the 19th or early 20th centuries have apparatus doors and other features that make them ill-suited to the 21st.

The facades on many of these buildings are constructed of limestone or are intricate and of a “character-defining” nature. Thus, they cannot be easily changed.  In addition, the buildings may have landmark status because of their cultural value.

According to the Georgetown Current, a community newspaper, Tim Dennee, a city preservation architect, says, “It’s kind of a quiet disaster”, referring to the number of fire stations, up to ten, that may require alteration.

One community preservationist suggested that the station housing Engine 28/ Truck 14, which has more EMS than fire runs, simply have ambulances rather than fire companies, which would presumably mean that the neighborhood would stop having fire emergencies,  surely a great relief to citizens.  Following this logic, it would make more sense to simply close the station altogether, vanquishing fire/EMS emergencies with one fell swoop.

Meanwhile, the DCFD is predictability antsy, as some renovation projects are seven years old and the condition of firehouses, E28/T14 being one of them, have necessitated their closure with the companies moved elsewhere.

It’s a fascinating issue because so many beautiful fire stations have been torn down and it would be unfortunate to have more destroyed for any reason.  Hopefully, sanity will prevail and these treasures will be carefully re-constructed to allow for the delivery of modern fire/EMS services.  DCFD personnel make a key point:  the narrow entrances are currently being damaged as rigs with as little as three inches of clearance try to “thread the needle.”

 

2 Comments

  • Larry Osborne says:

    You make the point that ambulances and apparatus are getting bigger, and ask the rhetorical question; “do we need more stuff?” Most of us would agree that we do need more “stuff” based in part on both the technology which we face, and which is also now available to us. The question which some of us are beginning to discuss, especially in the current economic climate, is do we need it on every or even most pieces of apparatus?

    During the mid-1960′s, prior to the consolidation of Jacksonville and Duval County, Florida, one County station presented a problem similar to that described in the article. Cab-over fire apparatus had simply become too high to fit in the station. The County simply purchased a one-off engine-forward pumper, which also happened to be the County’s first 1000 gpm pumper. It later served the consolidated City. Several older cab-forwards remained in the fleet long enough to provide adequate spares for this station, when needed.

    The need for greater crew size and eliminating riding on the tailboard eventually necessitated the replacement of this station. That seems less of a problem for the historic old urban stations which Eric describes. It is a dialog involving operational necessities, economic realities, and irreplacable history, and a dialog worth having.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FE Talk: Humpday Hangout

Recent Posts
Comments
EMT RJ-FL
Legacy of the Big Black Buck
Your post brought a smile of rememberence of the "blaxplotation" movies of ths 70's such as mandingo. The relations and myths are still evident today as you said (so i guess that events in ferguson aint much of a suprise)..but in the same breath i say the only way you change a perception is by…
2014-11-26 18:39:26
Eric Lamar
Safety: Hillsborough at 25
J- Thanks for writing. Eric
2014-11-25 22:09:46
Jim Malone
Safety: Hillsborough at 25
The tragic deaths of Liverpool fans at Hillsborough was the result of a criminally corrupt police force showing utter contempt for the Health and Safety of the citizens they are paid to protect. The establishment cover up post disaster has caused reverberations in British society for 25 years, the courage of the friends and family…
2014-11-25 20:50:42
Eric Lamar
Providence: A HoMo Horror
Bill, Thanks for writing and have a great thanksgiving. Eric
2014-11-24 14:45:39
Bill Hand
Providence: A HoMo Horror
As previously stated, there is almost always more to the story. Here in Houston our mayor who is female and openly gay is doing all she can to take away our FD benefits. I don't like her because of her agenda against firefighters. It has nothing to do with her gender or sexual preferences, but…
2014-11-23 20:51:22
IAFFLogo
January 2012
M T W T F S S
« Dec   Apr »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  

FireEMS Blogs eNewsletter

Sign-up to receive our free monthly eNewsletter

LATEST FIREFIGHTER NEWS

HOT FORUM DISCUSSIONS

LATEST ON FIRE ENGINEERING

FEATURED DISCUSSIONS