American Jihad: 1865-2014

The Inner Struggle

The news that Moner Mohammad Abu-Salah, a 22-year-old from Florida, was the driver of a huge truck bomb in a Syrian suicide attack has caused consternation here in the U.S. as officials express deep concern over his “radicalization.”

Abu-Salah has company.

Booth

Booth

He was a young American, almost always  in his twenties.

He came from a broken, troubled or dysfunctional  home.

His family often moved or relocated.

He was a poor or indifferent student, usually dropping out of school.

He engaged in fantasies to escape exterior pain.

At loose ends he latched onto a political or religious dogma offering a kind of structure or unifying worldview.

“He” is:

John Wilkes Booth-  27, assassinated Lincoln

Lee Harvey Oswald- 24, assassinated Kennedy

Arthur Bremer-  22, shot presidential candidate George Wallace

Eric Rudolph- 30, bombed Olympic Park and other locations

Timothy McVeigh- 27, bombed the A.P. Murrah Building

John Walker Lindh-  20, fought for the Taliban

Dzhokhar Tsarnaev- 27, was a Boston Marathon bomber

Tamerlan Tsarnaev- 20, was a Boston Marathon bomber

These purveyors of American mayhem all have strikingly similar details in their early backgrounds.

Oswald

Oswald

Oswald, Rudolph and McVeigh were trained in the military, Oswald as a Marine, the others in the Army.  In fact, both Rudolph and McVeigh were assigned to Fort Benning, Georgia. Booth, too, flirted with the militia.

Almost all came from a single parent household either through death or divorce.  Booth had the added complication of being illegitimate at a time when that was much cause for shame.

Oswald, Bremer and  McVeigh were described as being “shy” and “withdrawn” and Bremer and McVeigh were bullied.

Both Bremer and McVeigh, as young adults, were unable to satisfy their sexual drive.

Some developed vivid  fantasy lives, Oswald around power and omnipotence, McVeigh around retaliation for being bullied and Bremer to escape dysfunction and violence at home.

Almost all dropped out of school for one reason or another, perhaps an early signal of a lack of socialization or an inability to fit in.

The Key

Without their acts of infamy they would, for the most part, be cast as losers lost in the mists of time.

In each case, already inclined toward instability, and with an apparent sense of grandiosity they came into contact with religious or political dogma that seems to have represented order, certainty and perhaps deliverance from anxiety.

Oswald said it best, “I was looking for a key to my environment and then I discovered Marxist literature.”

Adrift in society they suddenly found a “spiritual” anchor that helped to explain their discomfort and which pointed to a path forward.

They suddenly fit in; they were no longer alone.

Booth’s key was his belief that through his personal action the south would rise again.

Bremer’s purpose was “to do something bold and dramatic, forceful and dynamic, a statement of my manhood for the world to see”, as if violence was a surrogate for male virility. (In our culture it may be.)

McVeigh’s stated purpose was anti-government hate fueled by Ruby Ridge and the Siege in Waco though sexual frustration may also play a role.  And, like Booth, he hoped to kindle a revolution.

Rudolph’s was anti-abortion and hate for homosexuals.

For Lindh and a host of others not discussed here but fitting the demographic, it was radical Islam.

Booth, McVeigh and Rudolph were all racist or exposed to racist culture and the militia movement is fraught with white supremacy such as the Aryan Nation.

When arrested, McVeigh was wearing a T-shirt  of Abraham Lincoln with the motto: sic semper tyrannis (‘Thus always to tyrants’), the words Booth shouted as he leapt to the stage after he shot Lincoln.

Both Booth and McVeigh hoped to inspire revolts.

Did McVeigh know all he shared in common with Booth?

McVeigh

McVeigh

Radicalism–Really?

The problem with assigning responsibility to radicalism is that radicalism is in the eye of the beholder.

It is a shifting definition of thought and speech in a country where freedom of both is held dear.

The real issue is a propensity toward violence of almost an apocalyptic nature perhaps to fulfill dark inner needs originating in childhood or early years.

Hate-filled religious and political dogma provided a pseudo-logic and the final step is simply deciding on the method and place to deploy violence.

In our society the tools of mayhem, weapons and improvised explosive devices, are readily at hand.

In our midst are deeply troubled young men empowered by their inner dysfunction and external messages of hate and the apocalypse.

We are largely at their mercy and the capricious  nature of fate and circumstance.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

5 Comments

  • Victoria Huckenpahler says:

    I agree, Eric. We have a number of malcontents here who are ripe for being plucked by extremist groups. It’s heartbreaking really. I feel for these people to a degree because they are really hurting, and think the ideology they adopt will reverse the hurt. Not only does it not do that, but have you ever noticed how many perpetrators, particularly of the school crimes we’ve seen so much of lately, end as suicides? It’s very telling, and indicates that we have to do more at the level of education and mental health to prevent the devastation to both criminal and victims.

  • Glenn says:

    Great work Eric. A contributing factor to this condition (that continues today) is the prevailing view by most males that seeking counsel or medical help undermines the manhood of the male species.

    • Eric Lamar says:

      Thanks, Glenn.

      It also seems that people around them often know something is amiss but don’t act perhaps because they are unsure of what to do.

      One example of that is Hasan, the Fort Hood shooter, who was a mental health professional, himself. His behavior was flagged in writing, including that he was emailing Al-Awlaki.

  • michael says:

    Powerful stuff Eric, keep up the great work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

FE Talk: Humpday Hangout

Recent Posts
Comments
Bob Gray
Ebola: The Real Lesson
Good advice, Eric...well taken.
2014-10-29 19:06:27
Eric Lamar
Ebola: The Real Lesson
WOW. Quite a story, Cortez. Thanks for sharing. Eric
2014-10-29 14:39:21
Cortez Lawrence
Ebola: The Real Lesson
Eric: You certainly have it right. My back surgery three and a half years ago left me unable to walk because of a hospital contracted infection that caused a spinal abcess and required a followed on surgery and an additional week in the hospital and 3 months of PIC line and high explosive antibiotics! I…
2014-10-29 14:28:11
Eric Lamar
Ebola: The Real Lesson
G- Thank you for sharing your experience. Eric
2014-10-28 17:52:17
Glenn
Ebola: The Real Lesson
Good stuff Eric. Our daughter while receiving chemo treatments was infected with staph when the port the hospital personnel inserted became infected. She became extremely ill. She was of course already weakened by the chemo. It cost us over $18,000 for interventions antibiotics, later reimbursed by the hospital after I complained all the way up…
2014-10-27 19:51:00
IAFFLogo
August 2014
M T W T F S S
« Jul   Sep »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

FireEMS Blogs eNewsletter

Sign-up to receive our free monthly eNewsletter

LATEST FIREFIGHTER NEWS

HOT FORUM DISCUSSIONS

LATEST ON FIRE ENGINEERING

FEATURED DISCUSSIONS